Political Parties Shouldn’t Discriminate, But They Can Recognize That Voters Do
565 words
In a recent commentary in the New York Times, Thomas B. Edsall cites research indicating that men considering themselves highly masculine were far more likely to have voted for Donald Trump than men who do not consider themselves highly masculine.
If this research is valid it would be compatible with the fact that both of Mr Trump’s election victories were over women--- Hillary Clinton in 2016 and Kamala Harris in 2024? And that the only election that Trump lost (despite his consistent claims that he won it) was against Joe Biden, a male.
As Edsall notes, the political differences between the two cohorts of males are far bigger than those between men and women, which themselves are substantial. And these differences are rooted in deep psychological factors.
The political implications of this research are very troubling, but they are quite clear. If Democrats want to win the White House in 2028 their nominee may need to be a heterosexual male.
This of course does not mean that heterosexual males have a monopoly on the talents and temperaments to be excellent presidents. I can think of many female Democrats who would be excellent presidents, offhand--- women like Stacey Abrams or Amy Klobuchar.
Likewise I certainly think that a gay male like Pete Buttigieg could be an excellent president.
But to become president one must first get elected, and the research cited by Thomas Edsall suggests that nominees like Buttigieg, Abrams, or Klobuchar would face strong headwinds in a national election, even though all of them have won lower elective offices.
Of course political parties should not discriminate on the basis of gender or sexual orientation. However political parties are not being discriminatory if they recognize the extent that substantial portions of the electorate are going to vote in a discriminatory way and take that unpleasant fact into account in deciding who they are going to nominate.
Given America’s history of racial discrimination, it is interesting that a Democrat like Barack Obama was able to get elected and re-elected in spite of his race. But Obama is a heterosexual male.
In the light of the research cited by Edsall, it is even conceivable that Donald Trump’s sexual bragging and reputation actually increased the number of people who voted for him rather than reducing it. After all, he was at least posing as a hyper masculine man.
And also in this light, one can understand the political reasons behind Trump’s nomination of Pete Hegseth, who puts on a show of extreme masculinity, and calling him the “Secretary of War.”Hegseth’s decision to require all males in our military forces to take annual testosterone tests also fits neatly into Edsall’s analysis.
Keeping our leaders under public control requires an opposition party that has a reasonable chance of winning the next election. So in 2028 Democrats should select a presidential candidate with a decent chance of winning. As I have already indicated, that nominee will probably have to be a heterosexual male.
A Democrat who wins will be free to appoint talented women and gay people to the cabinet and to the Supreme Court, and as Joe Biden’s victory in 2020 shows he could have a gay or female running mate.
We can hope that some day soon this kind of strategic thinking about presidential nominations will no longer be important. But for the time-being it may be a political necessity.

